Join our FREE personalized newsletter for news, trends, and insights that matter to everyone in America

Newsletter
New

Texas Apartment Manager Says My Lease Transfer Isn’t Valid Because New Tenants Never Picked Up Their Keys — But The Contract And Her Own Emails Say Otherwise. What Are My Rights?

Card image cap

Hi everyone — I’m in Austin, TX and need advice about a lease-transfer dispute.

I signed a Texas Apartment Association (TAA) Lease Change / Transfer Addendum to remove myself from a lease. It was fully signed by me, the two new tenants, and management. I moved out completely, turned in keys, and got an email confirming I’d been “moved out.”

A few days later the new tenants backed out. The manager originally emailed me:

“The lease change form is signed by both of them as well as you and it does say that it is a legally binding document — it is not your responsibility anymore.”

Now (a week later) she’s saying the transfer wasn’t effective because they “never picked up keys,” and that a box on Paragraph 3 (“old resident ☐ is / ☐ is not released from further liability”) wasn’t checked — calling it a “clerical error.” She’s offering to “end my lease early” with a 30-day notice and an 85% reletting fee.

But Section 12 (“Effective Date”) just says it’s effective once all parties sign, deposits are paid, and the owner approves — no mention of key pickup.

Questions:

  1. Does an unchecked box really undo a signed release?
  2. Can they legally put me back on the lease after confirming I was released in writing?
  3. Should I contact a tenant-rights or contract attorney now?

Location: Austin, TX

submitted by /u/goldlionfish
[link] [comments]