Move Over Hims & Hers Health: This Insurance Business Could Be The Next Monster Healthcare Stock (hint: It's Not Unitedhealth)

When it comes to healthcare stocks, many investors pay attention to the usual suspects: Eli Lilly, Novo Nordisk, CVS Health, or Johnson & Johnson. These companies have built up enormous brand equity thanks to blockbuster drugs and widely recognized pharmacy management services.
With the exception of CVS, whose shares have risen 46% so far this year, none of the other companies have generated robust stock price returns so far in 2025. Lilly, Novo, and Johnson & Johnson are seeing share price pressure over concerns that President Donald Trump's administrative actions could impact the pharmaceutical industry -- particularly as it relates to tariffs and medication pricing.
One healthcare player that is (so far) outmaneuvering investor trepidation throughout 2025 is telemedicine company Hims & Hers Health (NYSE: HIMS). Its share price is up 138% in 2025 (as of June 17). While buying into Hims and Hers stock to follow the momentum is tempting, I think a different, dirt cheap health insurance stock is positioned for a breakout akin to Hims & Hers Health. And no, I'm not talking about the beaten-down UnitedHealth Group.
Popular Products
-
Fireproof Document Bag with Zipper Cl...
$55.99$38.78 -
Acrylic Desktop File Organizer with 5...
$37.99$25.78 -
Child Safety Cabinet Locks - Set of 6
$21.99$14.78 -
Travel Safe Lock Box with 4-Digit Cod...
$146.99$101.78 -
Dual Laser Engraver
$5,068.99$3034.78