Business Secretary Dismisses Claim ‘shambolic’ Pre-budget Uncertainty Has Caused Hit To Growth – Uk Politics Live

Peter Kyle defends government as Reeves faces criticism about pre-budget briefings ahead of Wednesday announcement

Joel Hills, business and economics editor at ITV News, was not impressed by Peter Kyle’s claim on the Today programme that the pre-budget uncertainty has not been much of a problem for the economy. (See 9.30am.) Hill posted this on social media.

The business secretary, Peter Kyle, has just told Today that he “refutes” the assertion that three months of endless leaks, briefings and speculation about which taxes will rise in the Budget has harmed the economy. The governor of the Bank of England is clear that it has.

We’ve had month upon month of speculation – fiscal fandango, basically. And that’s been costly for the economy. It’s caused paralysis among business and consumers. It’s the single biggest reason why growth has flatlined, it’s been grounded in the second half of the year.

There are a number of data points that suggest that the prolonged speculation has flatlined growth. You see this in the latest retail sales numbers, which were the first to decline since May.

You see this in the decline of business confidence and consumer sentiment.

This whole run into the budget has been really difficult and I think that in any future budgets lessons will be learned not to indulge in the constant technically pitch rolling – all these different ideas being inflated and then withdrawn and then tried again. It’s been really confusing to businesses and it’s unnecessary … This frankly pretty shambolic process in the run into [the budget] has been unhelpful.

The biggest single challenge to growth in this country is the inheritance this government had. The Brexit deal alone has taken 4% of GDP off the whole economy. That is a fact. It far outweighs anything that speculation could and did cause.